Reducing Taxes on Utility Batteries in New York

What New York State law gives, what a local agency can add, and what stays.

Download the report (PDF)

Goal

Show which taxes a standalone battery project in New York can remove, who decides, and what to do first.

This report is written from a New York perspective. It covers New York State and New York local tax law only. Other states may have different tax laws, so these findings may not apply outside New York.

No New York sales tax break

Not for commercial batteries

A local agency can grant one

Property tax: 15 years off

Automatic under New York law

Unless a local body opted out

No PILOT for a battery alone

That law names solar and wind only

Appoint first, buy second

The exemption starts with the appointment

Plain words

IDA:
industrial development agency. A New York local public body that can grant tax breaks to a project.
PILOT:
payment in lieu of taxes. A yearly payment agreed in place of property tax.
Section 487:
the section of the New York Real Property Tax Law that exempts energy systems from property tax.
Mortgage recording tax:
a tax paid when a mortgage is recorded.
Agent:
a project the IDA appoints to buy things in the IDA's name.
Opt out:
a local vote to refuse the Section 487 exemption.

1. The four taxes

A standalone battery project in New York, privately owned.

State 1 of 4

No relief: four taxes leave the project

Sales tax, property tax, mortgage tax and the utility’s tax lines.

Line drawing: a fenced battery yard with one battery enclosure, a control cabinet and a transformer; a stack of equipment crates at the gate; a town hall; a columned records building; and two utility polesSales taxProperty taxMortgage recording taxUtility taxes on upgrade costs
Figure 1. Four taxes and what each relief does to them.
TaxWho collects itReliefWho decides
1. Sales tax on equipmentNew York State and countyIDA exemption[T3]The IDA
2. Property taxTown, county, school districtSection 487 for 15 years, or an IDA PILOT[T1][T8]New York State law. Local bodies can opt out. The IDA.
3. Mortgage recording taxCountyIDA exemption[T5][T7]The IDA
4. Utility taxes on upgrade costsThe utilityNone found for the income tax line[T9]No one local

2. Sales tax

Tax on the battery equipment and other purchases.

Eastern Towhee A, Brooklyn. 4.9 MW. Sales tax exemption up to $1,110,041.[T4]

$1,110,041

That is $226,539 per MW. (Gaiergy arithmetic)

Lighthouse Luyster Creek I, Astoria. 56 MW. Sales tax and part of mortgage tax, up to $7,055,625.[T5]

$7,055,625

That is $125,993 per MW. (Gaiergy arithmetic)

KCE NY 1, Stillwater. 20 MW (size from a state press release; unconfirmed). Sales tax $584,500 and mortgage tax $30,000.[T7]

$584,500 and $30,000
0$8,000,000

(The $30,000 bar is drawn wider than its true length so it can be seen.)

Figure 2. Tax breaks that New York IDAs gave to standalone battery projects.
ProjectSizeIDAApprovedBenefit
Eastern Towhee A, Brooklyn4.9 MW, 19.6 MWhNew York City IDAJuly 21, 2026Sales tax exemption up to $1,110,041[T4]
Lighthouse Luyster Creek I, Astoria56 MW, 224 MWhNew York City IDASeptember 15, 2026Sales tax and part of mortgage recording tax, up to $7,055,625[T5]
KCE NY 1, Stillwater20 MW (unconfirmed)Mechanicville-Stillwater IDASeptember 10, 2018State sales tax $334,000. Local sales tax $250,500. Mortgage recording tax $30,000[T7]

3. Property tax

Tax on the value the battery adds to the land.

$139,118

Property tax exempted, 2024

The PILOT was 11% of the exempted tax.

$14,714

PILOT paid, 2024

Figure 3. KCE NY 1 in 2024: the yearly PILOT against the property tax it replaced.[T7]

4. What these routes do not remove

Charges on the utility’s bill for grid upgrades (National Grid).

5. What to do, in order

1

Check for opt-outs: town, county, school district.[T1]

2

Apply to the IDA.

3

The IDA appoints the project as its agent. It files Form ST-60 within 30 days.[T3]

Do not buy before this point
4

Buy equipment. Give each vendor Form ST-123.[T3]

5

Build before January 1, 2030.[T1]

6

File Form RP-487 with the town assessor.[T1]

7

Each year: file Form ST-340.[T3]

Figure 4. The order of steps. Purchases made before the appointment are not covered. (Gaiergy reading of the New York State tax bulletin)[T3]

6. Questions for a tax attorney

  1. Does the Section 487 PILOT clause reach a battery with no solar?
  2. Can IDA agent status remove the 8% sales tax line on a National Grid upgrade bill?
  3. Does leased land change the sales tax on installation? The 2009 New York State advisory opinion speaks of property “owned by Petitioner (i.e., not leased property)”.[T2]
  4. Is an IDA PILOT worth its fees where Section 487 already applies?

This is research. A New York tax attorney should confirm it before a project relies on it.

Details

Exact words from the sources

SourceExact words
T1“an electric energy storage system approved by the State Energy Research and Development Authority is exempt from taxation for a period of 15 years to the extent of any increase in assessed value due to the system”
T1“electric energy storage equipment and electric energy storage systems must be constructed after January 1, 2018 and before January 1, 2030”
T1“may require the owner of a property which includes a solar or wind energy system to enter into a contract for payments in lieu of taxes”
T2“the flywheels are not used directly and predominantly in the production of electricity for sale by generating”
T2“A frequency regulation facility could use batteries to provide essentially the same function”
T3“The IDA must file Form ST-60 within 30 days of appointing an agent.”
T4“an exemption from City and State sales and use tax in an amount not to exceed $1,110,041”
T5“a partial exemption of City and State mortgage recording taxes and exemptions from City and State sales and use tax in an amount not to exceed $7,055,625”
T9“Tax Liability Applied to Capital” at 13.91%, and “Estimated Sales Tax (8%)”

How the numbers were checked

Sources

Each source is a public document at the address shown.

Download the report (PDF)