Operational Considerations When Pairing Batteries with Solar

An animated diagrammatic explanation.

Download the report (PDF)

Goal

Show what equipment keeps a 5 MW solar array and a 5 MW battery from sending more power to the grid than the utility study allows.

Do not exceed the solar export permit

Unless the line already has spare capacity

Or the economics favor paying for upgrades

The utility sets the export limit

Through its interconnection study

Invest in redundant export-limiting equipment

A controller plus a backup protection relay

The safety the utility requires

Example: 5 MW solar, 5 MW battery, export limit 5 MW. The real limit comes from the utility study.

Situation 1

No limit: the problem

The trip opens:

Without control, the electric utility counts solar plus battery: 10 MW on the circuit.

Line drawing of the site: solar array, fenced equipment yard with inverter skid, battery enclosure, control cabinet and transformer, and two utility polesSolar invertersBattery invertersStep-up transformerUtility meterUtility recloserInverter stop signal
Site main breaker
Power plant controller
Protection relay with directional power control
Lockout relay (86)
Figure 1. The site. The numbers match the diagram below.
Alarm: export is over the limitSite offline. Locked out until a technician resets it.
13.2 kV site busElectric utility13.2 kV feedermeasures exportsets outputtriptripstop signal (gate block)Solar arrayBattery13.2 kVPower plant controllerProtection relay withdirectional power control(DTT - Direct Transfer Trip)PCCMRLockout relay (86)Controller failedLine sensors:6.5 MW.Limit: 5 MW.Trip signalTrip signalGate blockedGate blockedLocked outLocked outSolar 5.0 MW outBattery 5.0 MW out(discharging)Export 10.0 MWExport at the PCC0 MW5 MW10 MWExport limit 5 MW123345678910
Figure 2. One-line diagram. Situations play in order. Use the buttons to pause or pick a situation.

Equipment key

  1. 1
    Solar inverters.

    Turn solar power into grid power. They accept an output limit from the controller.

    Owner: the site.

  2. 2
    Battery inverters.

    Charge and discharge the battery. They accept an output limit from the controller.

    Owner: the site.

  3. 3
    Step-up transformers.

    Raise the voltage to the 13.2 kV site bus.

    Owner: the site.

  4. 4
    Site main breaker.

    The switch the relay opens.

    Owner: the site.

  5. 5
    Power plant controller.

    The daily limiter. It measures export at the PCC and tells both inverter groups what to do.

    Owner: the site.

  6. 6
    Protection relay with directional power control.

    The backstop. Utility grade, with its own current and voltage sensors. It trips the breaker if export goes over the setting. It can open the site main breaker, the utility recloser, or both.

    Owner: the site, or the electric utility inside its recloser.

  7. 7
    Utility meter.

    Measures what crosses to the grid.

    Owner: the electric utility.

  8. 8
    Utility recloser with remote control.

    The electric utility can open it from its control room.

    Owner: the electric utility.

  9. 9
    Lockout relay (device 86).

    The trip signal rarely goes straight to the breaker alone. It energizes this relay. The lockout relay trips the breaker or the recloser and holds it open until a technician resets it by hand. The plant cannot reconnect to a dead grid by accident.

    Owner: the site, or the electric utility.

  10. 10
    Inverter stop signal (runback or gate block).

    Some utility schemes also send the trip to the power plant controller or straight to the inverters. The inverters stop current within milliseconds. That reduces wear on the breaker or recloser contacts as they open.

    Owner: the site.

Excerpts from one electric utility

RuleExact wordsSource
The study uses the declared limit“operating characteristics including maximum export and import capacity shall be utilized, except that fault current contribution shall be evaluated based on aggregate AC nameplate rating”The state rule this utility follows [E1]
A limited site needs a relay“For energy storage systems or distributed generation where net export is limited, Reverse Power (Function 32) shall be required.”The state rule this utility follows [E1]
The utility wants utility grade controls“The customer shall utilize a power limiting scheme (e.g. 32 element) with utility grade controls. PT, CT, and relay percent error will be factored into the final setpoint of the 32 element.” (32 element: a protection relay with directional power control.)The utility's own bulletin, Section 7.6.14 [E2]
A lockout relay has a standard device number“86 Lock Out Relay” (From the bulletin's table of device numbers.)The utility's own bulletin [E2]
What a stop signal makes the inverters do“Cease to Energize: Cessation of energy flow capability.”The state rule this utility follows [E1]

Three things to plan for

Another way to build it

It depends on where the solar inverters are.

The rules name both layouts: DC coupled and AC coupled.[E1 Appendix K, page 2][E2 Section 5.1.1.4, page 11]

Form 1

One main inverter: the battery sits behind it

Line drawing of the site with one main inverter skid in the yard next to the battery enclosureOne main solar inverterBattery joins on the DC sideDC link
Figure 3. One main inverter. The battery connects to it on the DC side.
Midday
DC sideAC sideDC/DCOne main inverter,5 MWPCCMRElectric utility13.2 kV feederSolar 5.0 MWBattery 2.0 MW in(charging)Inverter output3.0 MW05 MW rating
Figure 4. The inverter rating is the ceiling. The site cannot send more than 5 MW.
  • Nameplate is 5 MW, not 10 MW. The one inverter sets it.[E1 Appendix K, page 2]
  • Fault current is studied at 5 MW.[E1]
  • If the study limit is below 5 MW, the controller and the relay from Figure 2 are still needed.[E1]
  • Trade-off: the array and the battery share one 5 MW path. The battery charges from the grid only if the inverter works in both directions.
Form 2

Many small inverters across the array: use Figure 2

Line drawing of the site with a small inverter at the end of every panel row and no inverter skid in the yardA small inverter at each rowBattery with its own invertersController and relay
Figure 5. Small inverters at the rows. Each one sends grid power from its own row.
Midday
sets outputmeasures exporttrip13.2 kVsite busmore rows5 MWProtection relay withdirectional power controlPCCMRElectric utility13.2 kV feederPower plant controllerSolar 5.0 MW outBattery 2.0 MW in(charging)Export 3.0 MWNameplate: 5 MW solar + 5 MW battery = 10 MW
Figure 6. No shared DC point exists. The battery needs its own inverters, and the controller must reach every small inverter.
  • There is no single point for the battery to sit behind. Each small inverter makes grid power at its own row.
  • The battery needs its own inverters. Nameplate adds up to 10 MW.[E1]
  • Use the Figure 2 equipment: the controller, the protection relay with directional power control, and the main breaker.[E1][E2 Section 7.6.14]
  • The controller must be able to turn down every small inverter. Confirm this with the inverter maker.

Excerpts on the two layouts

Exact wordsSource
“Indicate DER system nameplate rating based on the proposed project configuration, i.e., stand-alone, AC-coupled or DC-coupled.”The state rule, Appendix K, item d [E1]
“(2) Distributed Generator (DG) and ESS DC coupled; (3) DG and ESS AC coupled”The utility's own bulletin, Section 5.1.1.4 [E2]

Details

Abbreviations

CT, PT
current transformer and potential (voltage) transformer. Sensors that feed the relay.
Device 32
the standard number for a directional power relay.
Device 86
the standard number for a lockout relay.
Gate block
a command that makes an inverter stop current at once.
PCC
point of common coupling. Where the site meets the utility line.
kVA, MW
units of power. 5,000 kVA is about 5 MW.
DC coupled
the battery and the solar share one inverter.
AC coupled
each has its own inverters.
Direct transfer trip (DTT)
the utility opens the site's breaker from a distance, over a communication channel. The state rule defines it as “Remote operation of a circuit breaker by means of a communication channel.”[E1]

Sources

Each source is a public document.

Download the report (PDF)